Two women sitting together and one is comforting the other but she is really trying to manipulate emotions

Why (and How) Religious Cults Manipulate Emotions

ByMegan Von Fricken
Pinterest image with the text "How and why religious cults manipulate emotions"

Religious cults often manipulate emotions to keep people compliant, connected to the group, and unsure of their own instincts.

This post starts by defining emotion control within cult mind control, then lays out signs that it may be affecting you both while you’re still involved and after you’ve left.

From there, it breaks down common tactics on two sides of the same dynamic: emotions cults try to elicit, and emotions they pressure people to suppress.

It closes by looking at a few ways these emotional dynamics can contribute to religious trauma over time, plus a starting point for recovery support.

Religious cults, or high-control religions (HCR), use many tactics to influence nearly every part of members’ lives.

One of the most damaging is emotion control: the deliberate conditioning of what you’re allowed to feel, what you’re supposed to fear, and what you’re expected to be ashamed of.

Emotion control isn’t unique to religious cults. It also shows up in other authoritarian groups because it helps leaders maintain power and keep people compliant.

For many people, this can have significant lasting effects and can be part of what later shows up as religious trauma.

When I left Evangelical Christianity, I had to work hard to understand my emotions and identify the ways my emotional world had been influenced.

If you’re deconstructing your faith or deconverting from a religious cult, this will probably feel familiar to you too.

In this article, I’ll be walking through how religious cults manipulate emotions, and why these tactics can have such an intense and lasting impact on folks who experienced religious indoctrination.

  • If you’re new to the term “high-control religion,” I often use it interchangeably with “religious cults.” You can find out more about this here: What Is a High-Control Religion

What We’ll Be Covering:

What is Cult Mind Control?

Cult mind control (sometimes called thought reform or brainwashing) is the set of tactics religious cults use to influence how members behave, what information they can access, how they interpret reality, and what emotions feel “allowed.”

One of the clearest frameworks for understanding this is Dr. Steven Hassan’s BITE Model:

  • Behavior control: rules, rewards, and punishments that shape what you do.
  • Information control: restricting, censoring, or spinning information to protect the group’s narrative.
  • Thought control: pushing black-and-white thinking and discouraging doubt or critical questions.
  • Emotion control: using fear, guilt, shame, and emotional highs to keep people compliant.

For the purpose of this article, we’re focusing on emotion control, since it often has some of the most lasting effects after someone leaves.

However, if you want a deeper dive into all four areas of control, Dr. Hassan’s book Combating Cult Mind Control is a helpful place to start: Combating Cult Mind Control.

Signs Emotion Control May Be Affecting You

Emotion control can look different depending on the group, your life context, and what kinds of pressure you were under.

If you’re sorting through your own experience, it can help to look at two different seasons: what it felt like inside the religious cult, and what it can feel like after leaving.

While still involved in a religious cult

You might notice signs like:

  • Feeling guilty for having normal needs, boundaries, or preferences.
  • Monitoring your emotions in real time so you can present the “right” attitude (especially in prayer, worship, confession, or leadership settings).
  • Anxiety that spikes after missing services, praying “wrong,” or questioning leaders.
  • A habit of checking what you’re “supposed” to feel before you let yourself feel what’s actually there.
  • Shame that shows up quickly when you feel anger, grief, desire, or doubt.
  • Feeling responsible for other people’s salvation, faith, or emotional state.
  • Hiding distress because you worry it will be seen as sin, weakness, or lack of faith.

After leaving a religious cult

Some people notice:

  • Emotional numbness or flatness, especially around topics that used to feel spiritually urgent.
  • Waves of guilt or fear that show up out of nowhere (even when you logically disagree with the belief system).
  • Feeling “on edge” in everyday situations, like you’re waiting to get in trouble for doing something normal.
  • Difficulty trusting your own preferences because you were taught to doubt yourself.
  • Grief, anger, or relief coming in intense swings once you’re finally in a safer environment.
  • Feeling disconnected from community, identity, or purpose, even when leaving was the right choice.

These signs aren’t meant to be a diagnostic checklist, and they can also show up for reasons other than high-control religion.

But if several of them resonate, and you were also indoctrinated into a religious cult environment, it can be a clue that your emotional world was influenced in harmful ways.

Next, I’ll break down how religious cults create those dynamics, both by pulling for certain emotions and by pressuring people to suppress others.

Why Emotion Control Affects People Differently

Emotion control doesn’t impact all people in the same exact way.

Unfortunately, religious cults often build their rules around existing systems like patriarchy, white supremacy, ableism, and heteronormativity, which can intensify the emotional pressure on people who are already marginalized.

For example:

  • LGBTQ+ people may be pushed into shame and secrecy through “deliverance” language or constant scrutiny.
  • Disabled and chronically ill people may be pressured to perform wellness, to minimize pain, or to treat symptoms as a spiritual problem instead of a body and access issue.
  • People of color and immigrants can face added fear when the group is tied to cultural belonging, safety, or survival needs.

If you’re holding more than one marginalized identity, emotion control can feel less like a single tactic and more like a layered system of pressure that touches your body, relationships, and community.

It can also make leaving feel complicated or even unsafe, especially when your housing, finances, childcare, immigration status, disability support, or community safety is tied to the group.

The Role of Emotion Control in High-Control Religions

Emotion control is particularly harmful because it can influence how you trust your own needs, instincts, and emotional signals.

In religious cults, leaders often pull for certain emotions (like fear, guilt, and shame) while also pressuring people to suppress others (like anger, grief, doubt, and desire).

Below, I’m going to break down both sides of that dynamic so you can see how it works in real life, and why it can linger long after someone leaves.

How Religious Cults Elicit Specific Emotions

Religious cults don’t just “create feelings” for the sake of it. They pull for specific emotions because certain emotional states make people easier to influence.

For example, fear can make you more likely to comply while shame can keep you self-focused and self-policing.

Ultimately, intense emotional highs can create a sense of belonging that feels hard to question, even when something seems off.

Over time, these emotional dynamics can condition people to trust the group’s interpretation of what they’re feeling more than their own instincts.

What follows are some common emotional manipulation techniques you’ll often find in religious cults and high-control religions.

Love-Bombing

Religious cults often overwhelm new members with intense displays of affection, making them feel loved and accepted.

This creates a strong emotional bond that makes it harder to question or leave the group.

Examples:

  • A newcomer is invited to multiple dinners in the first week, told they’re “chosen,” and quickly treated like family.
  • When the person hesitates or asks questions, members respond with extra warmth and attention, which can make doubt feel like betrayal.

Fear Tactics

Cults instill fear by exaggerating external threats, such as the dangers of the outside world or divine punishment for leaving the group.

This fear keeps members isolated and compliant.

Examples:

  • People are warned that leaving will lead to spiritual ruin, demonic attack, or god removing protection.
  • Normal life choices (dating, college, therapy, friendships outside the group) are framed as doors that invite danger.

Guilt and Shame

Religious cults manipulate their members by instilling guilt and shame, often making them feel personally responsible for their “sins” or the salvation of others.

This can lead to cycles of self-blame and dependency on the group for redemption.

Examples:

  • If you feel anxious or depressed, you’re told you’re not trusting god enough or you’re “harboring sin.”
  • You’re reminded that someone’s salvation could be lost because you didn’t evangelize hard enough.

The “god-experience”

Cults often create emotional highs during services through carefully controlled settings—music, lighting, repetitive messaging—that members believe is a connection to the divine.

These orchestrated experiences are used to reinforce loyalty and belief in the cult’s doctrine.

Examples:

  • After an intense worship set, a leader urges people to commit, confess, or donate while emotions are running high.
  • If someone doesn’t feel the “high,” they may be told they’re resistant, prideful, or spiritually unsafe.

How Religious Cults Suppress Emotions

Eliciting emotions is one side of the coin. The other side is teaching people which emotions are “acceptable” and which ones make them a problem.

When a religious cult suppresses emotions like anger, grief, doubt, or desire, it limits the feelings that might alert someone that something is wrong.

It also cuts people off from the emotions that often support change, boundary setting, and leaving.

The result is a narrow emotional range that keeps the group’s authority intact, even when members are hurting.

What follows are some examples of how religious cults and high-control religions suppress members’ emotions.

Emotional Isolation

Members are often discouraged from expressing feelings that challenge the cult’s teachings.

Over time, this leads to a disconnection from emotions that are labeled “unfaithful” or “unspiritual.”

Examples:

  • When someone expresses doubt, they’re told to stop “being negative” and to talk only to approved leaders.
  • Private struggles are reframed as spiritual failure, which can make honest connection feel unsafe.

Forced Happiness

Cults often demand constant displays of positivity and happiness, creating a facade of contentment.

This forced happiness can result in emotional exhaustion and burn-out, especially when members are discouraged from seeking help.

Examples:

  • Grief is met with “just pray more” or “choose joy,” rather than support, rest, or care.
  • People learn to smile through panic or pain because sadness is treated as weakness or lack of faith.

Emotional Rigidity

Cults encourage black-and-white thinking, where emotions like doubt, fear, or sadness are deemed wrong.

This emotional rigidity prevents members from processing nuanced emotions and forces them to conform to the group’s expectations.

Examples:

  • Anger is labeled “bitterness,” boundaries are labeled “rebellion,” and questions are labeled “pride.”
  • People are taught to interpret complex feelings as a simple moral problem: righteous or sinful.

How Emotional Control Can Lead to Religious Trauma

When a religious cult repeatedly pulls for fear, guilt, and shame while discouraging anger, grief, or doubt, it can leave your body in a constant state of bracing.

Over time, that kind of pressure can influence how your brain and nervous system respond to stress, and it can contribute to the symptoms many people associate with religious trauma.

Below are three common ways this can show up. While aren’t actual diagnostic categories, they can help you identify why certain reactions can continue showing up in your day-to-day life long after leaving.

Burnout & Emotional Exhaustion

When people in religious cults feel pressured to push down their emotions for long periods of time, it can wear down their capacity to cope with stress.

Some research suggests this kind of chronic stress can increase threat sensitivity and make it harder to access the parts of us that help with planning, reflection, and emotion regulation.

As a result, people may start to feel burnt out, emotionally drained, or disconnected from what they feel.

Over time, some people also notice emotional numbness, which can overlap with PTSD symptoms and make it harder to process what happened.

Guilt, Shame & Unworthiness

Religious cults often use rigid moral standards that can keep people caught in chronic guilt and shame.

Over time, that can leave someone feeling like they’re never good enough.

Some researchers link shame to increased self-focused rumination, which can keep harsh inner narratives running.

Guilt is sometimes linked with increased bodily awareness and distress.

For many people, the practical impact is that feelings of unworthiness can stick around and feel hard to shake.

Cognitive Dissonance & Inner Conflict

Cognitive dissonance can happen when someone’s beliefs, values, or emotions don’t match what the group teaches.

That kind of inner conflict can increase stress and make daily life feel mentally and emotionally exhausting.

For some people, it can show up as anxiety, depression, or trauma-related symptoms.

To survive the tension, many people end up minimizing their own needs, pushing down feelings, or finding ways to explain away what doesn’t fit.

When those conflicts keep stacking up, the emotional toll can be significant.

Understanding this helps explain why emotion control can have a lasting impact on people who’ve been in religious cults.

If you want to explore some of the research behind how chronic stress, shame, and trauma show up in the brain and body, here are a few accessible starting points:

Recovering from Emotion Control

In this article, we’ve looked at how religious cults use emotion control to keep people compliant, both by eliciting certain emotions (like fear, guilt, and shame) and by pressuring people to suppress others (like anger, grief, doubt, and desire).

If you’re noticing lingering guilt, shame, fear responses, emotional numbness, or inner conflict after leaving, that can be part of the fallout of living under those dynamics for a long time.

Recovery often takes time, especially when your body and relationships had to adapt to constant pressure.

For many people, getting support from a qualified professional who understands religious trauma and cult recovery can make a real difference, and can help you rebuild trust in your own emotional signals as you move forward.

Ultimately, recovery is about learning to trust what you feel again, at your own pace, with support that respects your full story.

Some Possible Next Steps

If this article resonated with you and you’re wondering where to go from here, you might consider the following options:

If you’re ready to do some focused work around religious deprogramming or nervous-system recovery, and you want to work with someone who “gets it,” you might consider working with me one on one.

I am a trained psychotherapist and now offer clinically-informed coaching for clients world-wide who are trying to make sense of their experience with religious indoctrination and heal at a deeper level.

Learn More

If you found value in this post, consider sharing it to your favorite social media platform or send it directly to a friend who could benefit from the content.

Religious harm thrives in the dark, so the more we can all work together to shine a light on some of these issues, the more likely it is that others will find the same freedom from coercive control that we have found.

The Religious Harm Recovery Community is an intentional space where folks who have left a high-control religion can connect with others who “get it.

Get Started

*Members must be subscribed to the Religious Harm Recovery newsletters I send out twice a week.

Related Articles